Edmond Fence Source

Home / Common Mistakes When Setting Fence Posts

Common Mistakes When Setting Fence Posts

Blurred interior view through a chain link fence in industrial setting in Edmond, OK
Blurred interior view through a chain link fence in industrial setting in Edmond, OK

Most fence lines that lean, wobble or split along the bottom rail were set up to fail on the first day, in the hole, long before any weather reached them. The panels and pickets get the attention, but the posts carry the load, and a handful of avoidable mistakes during setting decide how long the whole fence stays straight.

What follows are the errors that show up again and again, why each one matters and what to do instead.

Skipping the utility locate

Digging before buried lines are marked is the most serious mistake on the list, because it is the one that can hurt someone. Gas, power, water, cable and fiber lines often run along property edges, exactly where fences go. Calling 811 before digging starts the free locate process, and utilities mark their lines with paint or flags. Private lines, such as a sprinkler system, a line to a detached garage or a landscape light circuit, are not covered by the public locate, so the owner needs to know or find those separately.

Holes that are too shallow

A post resists wind by leverage. The deeper it sits, the more soil holds it against the push of the panel above. A common rule of thumb is to bury roughly a third to a half of the above-ground height, and deeper for gate posts, corner posts and tall privacy fences. Holes also need to reach below the local frost depth so freezing ground cannot lift the post. Local building departments publish the frost depth for their area.

Shallow holes save time on the day and cost it later, when a stormy spring pushes the fence over in sections.

Holes that are too narrow, or shaped like a bell

The hole should be wide enough to surround the post with a good collar of concrete or compacted fill, typically around three times the width of the post. Too narrow and there is not enough material to grip.

The opposite shape problem is a hole wider at the top than the bottom. That cone or bell shape lets the frozen or swelling soil grab the wide top of the concrete and lift it. A hole with straight sides, or slightly wider at the bottom, resists that lifting.

No drainage at the bottom

Setting a wood post directly on soil at the bottom of the hole, then filling around it with concrete, creates a cup. Water runs down the side of the post, collects at the base and has nowhere to go. The bottom of the post sits wet for long periods and rots from the end grain up.

A layer of gravel at the bottom of the hole, with the post resting on it, lets water drain away from the end grain. Some installers also leave the bottom of the post exposed to the gravel rather than fully encased.

Metal posts meet the same problems

Steel and wrought iron posts set in concrete fail at the same point as wood: the line where the post meets the concrete and the air. Water collects there and corrosion starts beneath the paint, out of sight. For the details on how that happens, the earlier article on wrought iron that rusts below the visible line gives the complete walkthrough of what goes on where a metal post enters its footing, and why the damage is usually worse than it looks.

Concrete that sheds water toward the post

The top of the concrete collar should be crowned slightly so it slopes away from the post, shedding rain. A flat or dished top holds water against the wood right at ground level, which is exactly where posts rot first. Finishing the concrete just above grade, with a smooth slope away from the post, helps.

The wrong lumber

Not all treated lumber is meant to go in the ground. Pressure treated wood is labeled for its use, and posts need lumber rated for ground contact. Wood rated only for above-ground use will rot much faster when buried. Checking the end tag before buying avoids the issue.

For steel posts, look for galvanized posts and add caps so rain cannot run down inside the tube and rust it from within.

Not checking plumb on two faces

A post can look straight from the front and still lean toward the street. Checking with a level on two adjacent faces, and bracing the post in both directions while the concrete cures, keeps it plumb. Temporary braces from scrap boards staked into the ground work well.

No string line

Setting each post by eye produces a fence that wanders. A string line pulled tight between the end and corner posts, at a consistent height and offset, gives every line post a reference. Corner and end posts go in first, then the string, then the line posts.

Spacing should match the rail or panel length. Measuring each spacing from the center of the last post, rather than guessing, keeps panels from ending up too short or too long at the end of the run.

Rushing the load

Concrete needs time to gain strength before rails, panels or gates hang from the posts. Hanging a heavy gate on a post set that morning is one of the most common ways to end up with a gate that sags within weeks. Follow the cure time on the concrete product, and longer in cool weather.

Undersized gate and corner posts

Gate posts carry swinging loads; corner and end posts carry the tension of the whole run. Using the same size post as the line posts, at the same depth, is a frequent cause of sagging gates and leaning corners. Larger posts set deeper, with more concrete, hold those loads better.

Ignoring the soil

Soil type changes how posts behave. In Edmond, much of the ground is reddish clay that swells when soaked and shrinks during dry summers. That seasonal movement pushes and pulls on posts year after year. Practical adjustments in clay include:

  • Deeper holes, so more of the post sits in soil that moves less.
  • Gravel at the bottom and around the base for drainage, since clay holds water.
  • Avoiding backfilling with the same clay without compacting it in thin layers.
  • Not setting posts in clay that is saturated after heavy rain, when holes can slump and the concrete mix gets diluted by water in the hole.

Central Oklahoma spring storms bring strong straight-line winds, so a privacy fence there catches a lot of force. Posts set shallow in moving clay are the ones that lean first.

A setting checklist

  1. Call 811 and wait for the marks.
  2. Pull a string line and mark each post location.
  3. Dig straight-sided holes to the right depth and width.
  4. Add gravel at the bottom.
  5. Use ground contact rated wood or galvanized steel.
  6. Set, plumb on two faces and brace each post.
  7. Fill with concrete and crown the top away from the post.
  8. Wait for the cure before loading the posts.

Fences in older Edmond neighborhoods often show the results of skipped steps decades later, which makes them a useful guide to what lasts.

The posts at edmond fences desk cover repairs, gates and rust on iron fences, and nearly every one of those problems is easier to prevent at the post hole than to fix afterward.